Most link building campaigns fail before the first email goes out. The list is wrong: sites that sell links to anyone, sites with no real readers, or sites that would never cover your topic.
Link prospecting is the step where you find websites that could link to you, then filter them down to the ones worth pitching. Finding is the easy part. The filtering decides whether your outreach earns links that help, or links that waste budget and add risk.
This guide covers where good prospects come from, the exact checks to run on each site, the red flags that should remove a site from your list, and how to hand a clean list to outreach.
What is link prospecting?
Link prospecting is the research phase of link building. You build a list of relevant websites and specific pages that might link to your content, then qualify each one before anyone contacts the site.
A link prospect is one of those sites or pages: for example, a SaaS blog that already writes about your topic, a resource page that lists tools like yours, or an article that mentions your brand without linking.

Prospecting is separate from outreach. Prospecting answers “who should we contact and why?” Outreach answers “what do we say?” Mixing the two is how teams end up sending hundreds of generic pitches to sites that were never a fit.
Why prospecting decides whether link building works
Three things go wrong when the list is weak:
- Reply rates collapse, because editors ignore pitches that don’t fit their site.
- Budget goes to the wrong links, on sites with no readers, no topical match and no ranking value.
- Risk goes up. Sites that exist to sell links are exactly what Google’s spam policies describe as link spam, and links from them can be ignored or worse.
Search engines are not the only reason to care. AI assistants such as ChatGPT, Perplexity and Google’s AI Overviews build answers from pages they trust. A link or mention on a real publication your buyers read does more for that visibility than a placement on a site nobody visits.
How link prospecting works: a 4-step process

- Pick the target page and the reason to link. Decide which page needs links (a product page, a guide, a data study) and why an editor would link to it. Prospecting without a target page produces a list of “good sites” with no pitch.
- Find candidates. Pull sites from the sources in the next section. Aim for breadth here; you will cut most of them.
- Qualify every site. Run each candidate through the checks below and drop it at the first failure.
- Organize and hand off. Record the contact, the target page and the reason for the pitch, so outreach can personalize without redoing the research.
Where to find link prospects
The best source depends on the kind of link you want. Match the source to the campaign:
| Campaign type | Where to find prospects | What makes a good prospect |
|---|---|---|
| Guest posts and contributed articles | Search operators, competitor backlinks, industry publications your buyers read | Publishes expert contributor content with named authors and real editing |
| Resource and tool pages | Search operators like intitle:resources plus your topic | Page is maintained, recently updated and links out to genuinely useful tools |
| Unlinked brand mentions | Brand mention alerts, Google search for your brand name minus your own site | Already mentions you, so the ask is small. See the unlinked brand mentions guide |
| Lost and broken links | Your backlink tool’s lost links report, competitors’ broken pages | Linked to a page that no longer works. See link reclamation |
| Digital PR and expert quotes | Journalist request platforms such as Qwoted, Featured, Source of Sources and MentionMatch | Covers your industry and quotes practitioners |
| Competitor gap | Sites that link to two or more competitors but not to you (link intersect reports in Ahrefs or Semrush) | Already links to your category, so the topic fit is proven |
One correction to older guides: Cision renamed HARO as Connectively and shut that service down on December 9, 2024. Featured.com bought HARO in April 2025 and relaunched it, so it is an option again alongside the journalist platforms named above.
Search operators that still work
Google search operators are free and good for finding pages that tools miss. Here are four search patterns. Replace [your topic] with the subject of the page you want links to, and yoursite.com with your own domain:
"[your topic]" intitle:"write for us"finds sites that accept contributed articles"[your topic]" intitle:resourcesfinds resource pages in your topic"best [your topic] tools" -site:yoursite.comfinds roundups you could be added to"[your brand name]" -site:yoursite.comfinds mentions that may not link to you
Treat operator results as raw candidates. A “write for us” page tells you a site accepts pitches, not that it is worth a link. That is what qualification is for.
How to qualify link prospects: the checks I use
Third-party scores like Domain Rating or Domain Authority are useful for sorting a list, but they are easy to inflate and they say nothing about whether real people read the site. When I vet a site for a client campaign, it has to pass four checks, in this order. A site that fails one is dropped.

| Check | What to look at | Pass | Fail |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Topical relevance | The specific page and section where the link would sit, not just the homepage | A reader of that page would plausibly click through to your content | Site covers everything from crypto to recipes, or your topic would be forced |
| 2. Real organic traffic | Organic traffic estimate and its trend in Ahrefs or Semrush | At least 2,000 real monthly organic visitors and a stable or growing trend | Traffic collapsed after a Google update, or it comes from off-topic or spammy keywords |
| 3. A human editor | Named authors, author pages, sourced claims, consistent publishing | Someone reviews what gets published and can say no | Anything is published if you pay; posts credited to “admin” or “staff” |
| 4. Clean outbound links | Recent posts and their outbound links | Links out editorially, to sources that fit the article | Exact-match commercial anchors to casinos, loans, CBD or essay services; many unrelated paid-looking links per post |
The 2,000-visitor floor is the minimum I hold every placement to. It is not a magic number. It filters out the large group of sites that have authority metrics but no audience, which is where most link-selling networks live.
Red flags that remove a site immediately
- A public price list for “dofollow links” or “guest posts on DA 50+ sites”, sold to any niche
- A “write for us” page that is really a payment page
- The same network of sites appearing on every vendor list you are offered
- Recent posts that exist only to carry links, with thin content and no images or sources
- No real contact person, only a sales email or a marketplace listing
Google lists buying links for ranking, excessive link exchanges and automated link building as link spam. If a placement is paid, Google asks that the link be marked with rel="sponsored" (see Google’s guidance on qualifying outbound links). For a wider look at risky link patterns, see the toxic backlinks guide.
Tools for link prospecting
You need three kinds of tool. You don’t need all of them on day one.
| Job | Common tools | Free starting point |
|---|---|---|
| Find sites and check traffic | Ahrefs, Semrush, Moz, Majestic | Google search operators, Google Search Console’s Links report for your own site |
| Find the right contact | Hunter, Snov.io, Apollo | The site’s author pages, About page and LinkedIn |
| Track outreach | Pitchbox, BuzzStream, Respona | A shared spreadsheet |
How to organize your prospect list
Keep one row per prospect so outreach never has to redo your research. These columns are enough:
- Domain and the exact page where the link would fit
- Your target page and the one-sentence reason to link
- Traffic estimate and trend, plus the four checks (pass or fail)
- Contact name, role and email
- Status: not contacted, pitched, followed up, live, declined
The “reason to link” column matters most. If you can’t write it in one sentence, the prospect isn’t ready for outreach. When it is, the pitch almost writes itself; the outreach strategy guide covers the next step.
Common link prospecting mistakes
- Judging sites by DR or DA alone. A high score with no organic traffic is a warning, not a win.
- Checking the homepage, not the page. Relevance is decided by the article your link sits in.
- Prospecting without a target page. You end up pitching your homepage, which few editors will link to.
- Skipping the anchor plan. Decide in advance how links will be anchored. Most should be branded or descriptive, as explained in the anchor text guide.
What good prospecting looks like in practice
When Webisoft, a software development agency in Montreal, started working with us, the site had 51 referring domains and about 226 monthly organic visitors. Over 14 months we placed 280 niche-relevant links, every one on a site that passed the checks above. Organic traffic grew to 3,173 monthly visits, an increase of 1,304%. The full breakdown is in the Webisoft case study.
The point is not the link count. It is that every placement was on a relevant site with real readers, which is the part prospecting controls.
Should you do link prospecting in-house or outsource it?
Do it in-house if you have someone with time to vet sites one by one and a backlink tool subscription. Most of the cost is hours, not software.
Outsource when you need consistent volume, when your team keeps falling back on vendor lists, or when you lack existing editor relationships. If you outsource, ask any provider for their vetting criteria and a sample of live placements before you pay. Our link building services page shows how we run it.
Want to know which sites are linking to your competitors but not to you? Get a free link gap analysis, or see link building pricing.



